When Unlimited Potential Meets Limited Resources


July 16, 2021 – Nice name! And how appropriate. The name actually comes from a May 6, 2021 U.S. House of Representatives hearing staged by the Subcommittee on Railroads, Pipelines and Hazardous Materials. This hearing was over two months ago, but much of the discussion will have legs for the next year or three. The impact on Wisconsin Passenger Rail is yet to be seen. You can go to YouTube and watch the entire hearing…  all 4 hours and 45 minutes of it.  ZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz…………. Or you can catch some of my edits below.

Segment five video

The YouTube link above is for segment five. (I know I’m going backwards.) Here are some notes I made over what I thought was important discussion: About 49 minutes CA rep Doug LaMalfa’s monologue. About 39 minutes AR rep Bruce Westerman’s questions about cost per mile. About 26 minutes WA rep Marilyn Strickland questions/ exchange over HSR. About 16:15 minutes MA rep Seth Moultan questions/ exchange over the speed of HSR with Flynn of Amtrak.  A very interesting exchange, and one that shows how really splintered the information conveyed by the supporters of HSR can be. (Research this topic yourself on Wikipedia.)

By the way, each of these segments I have edited in questions from lawmakers from their five minute sessions, as opposed to watching the Q&A segments and getting scattered occurrences of questions and answers. 

segment two video

Segment two is Judge Trey Duhon from Waller County Texas, a well-spoken, well prepared testimony against Texas Central.  Any of you that are strong advocates of HSR should watch this and learn about the headwinds that are naturally going to happen with any NEW HSR project.  Even Mr. High Speed Rail Seth Moulton appeared effected by his testimony. 

segment four video

Segment four video is Texas Central CEO Carlos Aguilar.  I thought this would be a little more spicy coming off of Judge  Duhon’s testimony.  But I was wrong. 

segment three video

Segment three is John Porcari, former Deputy Secretary of Transportation under President Obama.  He’s currently the Secretary of Transportation for the State of Maryland. No question this gent received the most questions from lawmakers.  Considering his current status in transportation, this surprised me.  I think he answered questions in a rather level-headed manner.  There’s no outrageous marketing-type answers here. 

segment one video

Segment one is the opening statements from the two transportation chairs: Rep. Donald M. Payne Jr. from New Jersey and Rep. Peter DeFazio from Oregon. There is plenty of sizzle here, particularly if you watch segments two, three and five. Enjoy!